End spawn debate for good

[RevStoningpot]

Not sure if plug in is availible but i mentioned it and yukar suggested i make a suggestion as he belives a plug in could be made for a randomization of spawning. I'm thinking any where inside a 1 or 5Kish radius and of coarse beds would still work for a static respawn.
+No spawn camping
+No central wasteland (griefed, treeless, foodless)
+No spawn rats
+No spawn combat log
+Chance of starting right at some one's front door
+End of what to do with spawn topics

[Gnatogryz]

Yes.

[worldruler086]

this would basically put the nail on the coffin for the concept of it being vanilla, but sure. the only issue is that now, being 5k from spawn is irrelevant.

[LoneSoldier55]

Yeah, cause it's fun when someone repeatedly kills themselves until they get a spawn right over my base.

[RevStoningpot]

vanilla argument is invalid it's just a trade off one mod (spawn protection) for this one. and i doubt respawning as a form of exploration would be very efficient especialy if it's only a 1K radius in which you spawn

[LoneSoldier55]

I still like the idea of having a "Spawn" Zone instead of making it incredibly easy for noobs to get things. I like the wasteland because it makes a challange.

[RevStoningpot]

not a challenge to you just the noobs. but with the fact that spawn currently has decidedly been declared not reenterable than there is no reason for a spawn at all. and issues of resorces could be adjusted by the spawning area. like if it was only a 500R area for spawning you'd still be in treeless space

[FoSchnizzle]

Then add a plugin where new players start with a stack of wood and food. That would work just as well, no? See the point here? ANYTHING we would do is going to have a near valid argument going against it, and a near valid argument for it. No matter what happens, someone is going to not like it and leave, and chances are, that'll end up being a sad loss for the server. Unless it's someone that nobody likes... *cough cough* ;)

[LoneSoldier55]

I prefer it when people don't become threats. We only declare it not re-enterable because people complain about others escaping for good reason to it because they insist on fighting within the glowstone border.

[Bloop the poop]

Personally, for the sake of the server I think we should go without this plugin because we are straying furthur from the name of the server, SIMPLICITY. i like this plugin and it sounds useful, but i think going back to revs redesign of spawn thread would be a better idea. it sounds interesting, but removes the purpose of a map limit.